NEWSWIRETODAY Press Release& Newswire Distribution | HOME
MOST TRUSTED NEWSWIRE PRESS RELEASE DISTRIBUTION
PRTODAY / NewswireToday press release distribution service network
Written by / Agency / Source: Biblical Archaeology Society
Check Ads Availability|e-mail Article

Are you the owner of this article?, Turn it PREMIUM with your LOGO instead - and make it 3rd party Ads-Free! within the next hour!

The Reputation of the Israel Antiquities Authority is in Shambles - The Israel Antiquities Authority (IAA) has charged the owner of the James Ossuary, Oded Golan, with forging the inscription that reads
The Reputation of the Israel Antiquities Authority is in Shambles

 

NewswireToday - /newswire/ - Washington, DC, United States, 2008/11/03 - The Israel Antiquities Authority (IAA) has charged the owner of the James Ossuary, Oded Golan, with forging the inscription that reads "James, son of Joseph, brother of Jesus" on the ancient bone box.

   
 
Your Banner Ad Here instead - Showing along with ALL Articles covering Culture / History / Archeology Announcements

Replace these Affiliate Programs at ANYTIME! Your banner here within the next hour. Learn How!


 

The reputation of the Israel Antiquities Authority (IAA) is in shambles. After a nearly four-year trial (and still counting), 75 witnesses and more than 5,000 pages of testimony, what has been billed as the "forgery trial of the century" is about to collapse. The Israeli judge who will decide the case has advised the prosecution in open court to consider dropping the case. The evidence isn't there.

The story was reported by Matthew Kalman in the San Francisco Chronicle, and from there around the world. He described Judge Aharon Farkash's evaluation as a "humiliating collapse" of the government's case and "a major embarrassment ... for the [Israel] Antiquities Authority."

The principal target of the case has been the bone box inscribed "James, son of Joseph, brother of Jesus" that was brought to the world's attention in 2002 by the Biblical Archaeology Review in an article by Sorbonne epigrapher Andre Lemaire. The inscription, it was charged in the criminal indictment, was a forgery, engraved on an authentic stone box of the kind that Jews used 2000 years ago to rebury their dead--after a year following the initial burial when the flesh had decayed and desiccated.

The government's principal witness was Professor Yuval Goren, a former chair of Tel Aviv University's archaeology department, who testified that the forger had used a fake covering to conceal evidence of his forgery. But other witnesses suggested other ways this covering could have formed.

More importantly, on cross-examination Goren was forced to admit that after the police had removed this covering, he could see original ancient patina in the critical word "Jesus." With that, the case blew up.

This should not have been surprising. One of the members of the IAA's committee that long ago had declared the inscription a forgery, supposedly by a unanimous vote, had also written the IAA that she saw this original ancient patina in the engraving of the inscription.

Although the IAA advertised the committee's forgery decision as unanimous, it never was. Many members of the committee expressed no opinion, but the IAA registered them as "yes" votes. Others committee members relied on the commanding standing and reputation of Professor Goren. One member of the committee who would have found the inscription authentic said he was "forced" to change his mind because of Professor Goren's scientific analysis. In short, the committee, which included no non-Israeli, not even Professor Lemaire who had originally published the inscription in Biblical Archaeology Review and vouched for its authenticity, was bum-rushed into a supposedly unanimous decision.

At the trial, not a single expert in the Semitic script of the period testified that the inscription was a forgery. Nor did a single scientist back up Professor Goren's scientific testimony--and several scientists testified otherwise.

But it took several years to prove that the emperor had no clothes. This is a painful example of how the judicial process can be manipulated by unscrupulous bureaucrats. The Israel Antiquities Authority hates the antiquities market, which is where this inscribed ossuary came from. This supposedly drove the prosecution. Until now, it has been widely assumed by almost everyone who has mentioned the inscription publicly, based on the IAA committee's supposed unanimous decision and the ongoing forgery trial, that this inscription is a forgery. Now that will end.

But this is not the end of the matter. All the court can decide is that the prosecution has not proved its case beyond a reasonable doubt. Logically, the inscription can still be a forgery. It is never possible to prove to a 100 percent certainty that an inscription is authentic. Theoretically, there is always one more test that might reveal it to be a forgery. Even inscriptions found in professional archaeological excavations can be salted.

And there is still another question: Is the "Jesus" of this inscription the "Jesus" we know from the New Testament? All three of the names in the inscription--James (rather Jacob or Yaakov in its Hebrew form), Joseph and Jesus (Yehoshua in the Aramaic of this inscription) were very common among Jews at this time. Scholars are already discussing and writing about whether or not this inscription refers to Jesus of Nazareth. This is where the discussion should be--not in the hands of an official committee or in a criminal indictment.

Hershel Shanks is editor of Biblical Archaeology Review.

To arrange for an interview with BAR editor Hershel Shanks, please contact Sarah Yeomans. Contact information for other sources, including script experts Andre Lemaire of the Sorbonne and Ada Yardeni of Hebrew University, are also available.

 
 
Your Banner Ad Here instead - Showing along with ALL Articles covering Culture / History / Archeology Announcements

Replace these Affiliate Programs at ANYTIME! Your banner here within the next hour. Learn How!


 

Written by / Agency / Source: Biblical Archaeology Society

 
 

Availability: All Regions (Including Int'l)

 

Traffic Booster: [/] Quick NewswireToday Visibility Checker

 

Distribution / Indexing: [+]

 
 
# # #
 
 
  Your Banner Ad showing on ALL
Culture / History / Archeology articles,
CATCH Visitors via Your Competitors Announcements!


The Reputation of the Israel Antiquities Authority is in Shambles

Company website links NOT available to basic submissions
It is OK to republish and/or LINK any newswire for any legitimate media purpose as long as you name NewswireToday and LINK as the source.
 
Publisher Contact: Sarah Yeomans - Bib-Arch.org 
301-904-6641 syeomans[.]bib-arch.org
 
Newswire Today - PRZOOM / PRTODAY disclaims any content contained in this article. If you need/wish to contact the company who published the current release, you will need to contact them - NOT us. Issuers of articles are solely responsible for the accuracy of their content. Our complete disclaimer appears here.
IMPORTANT INFORMATION: Issuance, publication or distribution of this press release in certain jurisdictions could be subject to restrictions. The recipient of this press release is responsible for using this press release and the information herein in accordance with the applicable rules and regulations in the particular jurisdiction. This press release does not constitute an offer or an offering to acquire or subscribe for any Biblical Archaeology Society securities in any jurisdiction including any other companies listed or named in this release.

Culture / History / Archeology via RSSAdd NewswireToday - PRZOOM Headline News to FeedBurner
Find who RetweetFollow @NewswireTODAY

Are you the owner of this article?, Turn it PREMIUM with your LOGO instead - and make it 3rd party Ads-Free! within the next hour!


Read Latest Articles From Biblical Archaeology Society / Company Profile


Read Culture / History / Archeology Most Recent Related Newswires:

Fondazione Leonardo Presents 'Civiltà Delle Macchine' in Milan
Ancestry® Surpasses 15 Million Members in its DNA Network, Powering Unparalleled Connections and Insights
King’s Highway Trust Foundation Hosts Northeast Philadelphia History and Heritage Celebration
The ENGIE Foundation Signs A Partnership with the Greek National Opera to Promote Access to Culture for Underprivileged Children
Undersea Explorers Launch Kickstarter Campaign to Act as Proper Land Stewards of Historic Site
Ancestry.com, LLC Announces Participation in 35th Annual J.P. Morgan Healthcare Conference
My Performing Arts Agency MyPAA to Launch ARTERI
Special Guest George Romero At The Lucca Film Festival and Europa Cinema 2016
Belgium’s National Railway Museum - Train World Inaugurated in Brussels
Project Enye Launches EnyesCount - A Campaign to Count A Generation One Click At A Time
Singapore’s Oldest Museum Collaborates with A Master Perfumer to Mark it's 700 Years of History
Arts Center Organizes International Conference to Promote Intercultural Dialogue
Storied and Controversial Biblical Archaeology Magazine Turns 40
Vam Art, Inc. Organizes Convergence 2014 - An Exhibition of Modern and Contemporary Indian Art
Siren School Hosts Nationwide Jane Austen Event

Boost Your Social Network
& Crowdfunding Campaigns


LIFETIME SOCIAL MEDIA WALL
NewswireToday Celebrates 10 Years in Business


PREMIUM Members


Visit  La Bella Bakery Artisan Bakery Arizona

Visit  Limelon Advertising, Co.





 
  ©2021 NewswireToday — Limelon Advertising, Co.
Home | About | Advertise/Pricing | Contact | Investors | Privacy/TOS | Sitemap | FRANCAIS
newswire, PR press releases distribution service magazines engine news alert newsroom press room breaking news public relations articles company news alerts newswiredistribution ezine bizentrepreneur biznewstoday digital business report market search pr firms agencies reports distri-bution today investor relation successful internet entrepreneurs newswire distribution prtoday.com newswiredistribution asianewstoday bizwiretoday USA pr UK today - NOT affiliated with PRNewswire as we declined their partnership offer in 2013
 
PRTODAY & NewswireTODAY are proudly NOT affiliated with USA TODAY (usatoday.com)